Investigating the performance of the empirical models of SEDMODL2, STJ-EROS and WARSEM in estimating sediment yield from forest roads with different standards

Document Type : Complete scientific research article

Authors

1 Corresponding author, Assistant Prof., Department of Forestry, Faculty of Forest Sciences, Gorgan University of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, Gorgan, I.R. Iran.

2 Associate Prof., Department of Watershed management, Faculty of Rangeland and Watershed, Gorgan University of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, Gorgan, I.R. Iran.

3 Assistant Prof., Department of Forestry, Faculty of Forest Sciences, Gorgan University of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, Gorgan, I.R. Iran.

Abstract

Abstract
Background and Objectives: Forest roads are recognized as potential source of sediment production in forest watersheds. The aims of this research were to determine the performance of the empirical models in estimating sediment yield from forest roads and investigate the effect of technical standards of road on sediment yield.
Materials and Methods: In the forest roads of Bahramnia forestry plan, 30 segments which were suitable for sediment trap installation were determined. These segments were classified into low standard, standard and high standard segments based on some technical characteristics Such as average longitudinal slope, percentage of cutslope coverage, distance from runoff source to nearest reputation, traffic density, pavement condition, etc . Sediment yield from segments were measured after each rainfall event (from March 2019 to February 2020) with the use of trapping at the end of each segment.
The location of the trap was at the lowest point and adjacent to the reputation
Inside each trap, 5 graduated indicators were installed to repeat the measurements.
After each rainfall, sediment height (meters) and sedimentation area (square meters) were measured to calculate sediment volume. At the end of the year, three samples were prepared with the help of cylinders from each sediment trap to measure the apparent specific gravity of the sediment.Then estimated sediment yield by SEDMODL2, STJ-EROS and WARSEM was compared with real field values.
Findings: Results indicated the amount of clay, distance of runoff to culvert, amount of silt, ditch cover, bare soil on cutslope, road surface quality and traffic volume were respectively effective factors in sediment yield from roads. Annual sediment yield from roads with low standard (0.35 ton per year) was significantly more than standard roads (0.24 ton per year) and high standard roads (0.27 ton per year). The measured sediment yield from road segments (0.27 ton per year) was considerably less than estimated values by SEDMODL2 (1.74 ton per year), STJ-EROS (1.32 ton per year) and WARSEM (1.58 ton per year) models. Statistical analysis showed that only in roads with low standards there wasn’t significant difference between measured values and estimated values by models.
Conclusions: From the results of present study it can be concluded that none of models can estimate the annual sediment yield from forest roads of study area and all of them shows values more than real measured values. It is suggested that other models were evaluated and localized according to local properties.

Keywords: Road segments, Sediment trap, Performance of sediment estimation models, Road standard level, Bahramnia forest

Keywords

References

 1.Aust, W.M., Bolding, M.C., and Barrett, S.M. 2015. Best management practices for low-volume forest roads in the Piedmont region: Summary and implications of research. Transportation Research Record: J. of Transportation Research Board. 2472: 51-55.
2.Brown, K.R., Aust, W., and McGuire, K. 2013. Sediment delivery from bare and graveled forest road stream crossing approaches in the Virginia Piedmont. Forest Ecology and Management.310: 836-846.
3.Cao, L., Zhang, K., and Zhang, W. 2009. Detachment of road surface soil by flowing water. Catena. 76: 155-162.
4.Croke, J., Mockler, S., Fogarty, P., and Takken, I. 2005. Sediment concentration changes in runoff pathways from a
forest road network and the resultant spatial pattern of catchment connectivity. Geomorphology. 68: 3. 257-268.
5.Dymond, S.F., Aust, W.M., and Prisley, S.P. 2014. Application of a distributed process-based hydrologic model to estimate the effects of forest road density on stormflows in the southern Appalachians. Forest Science. 60: 6. 1213-1223.
6.Duff, M.J. 2010. Evaluation of road erosion prediction models applied to unpaved roads in a small tropical watershed in Eastern Brazil. M.Sc. Thesis, Faculty of Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University in Partial fulfillment, Biological Systems Engineering, 152p.
7.Foltz, R.B., Copeland, N.S., and Elliot, W.J. 2009. Reopening abandoned forest roads in northern Idaho, USA: Quantification of runoff, sediment concentration, infiltration, and interrill erosion parameters. J. of Environmental Management. 90: 2542-2550.
8.Fu, B., Newham, L.T.H., and Field, J.B. 2009. Modelling erosion and sediment delivery from unsealed roads in southeast Australia. Mathematics and Computers in Simulation. 79: 2679-2688.
9.Grace, J.M. 2005. Forest operations and water quality in the south. Trans. ASAE. 48: 2. 871-880.
10.Gyssels, G., Poesen, J., Bochet, E., and Li, Y. 2005. Impact of plant roots on the resistance of soils to erosion by water: a review. Progress in Physical Geography. 29: 198-217.
11.Jordán-López, A., Martínez, L., and Bellinfante, N. 2009. Impact of different parts of unpaved forest roads on runoff and sediment yield in a Mediterranean area. Total Environment. 407: 937-944.
12.Jones, J.I., Murphy, J.F., Collins, A.L., Sear, D.A., Naden, P.S., and Armitage, P.D. 2011. The impact of fine sediment on macro-invertebrates. River Research and Applications. 28: 8.1055-1071.
13.Lang, A.J. 2016. Soil erosion from forest Haul roads at stream crossings as influenced by road attributes. Thesis, Doctor of Philosophy in Forest Resources and Environmental Conservation, Faculty of the Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 158p.
14.Luce, C.H., and Black, T.A. 1999. Sediment production from forest roads in western Oregon. Water Resources Research. 35: 8. 2561-2570.
15.Moghadamirad, M., Abdi, E., Mohseni Saravi, M., Rouhani, H., and Majnounian, B. 2013. Effect of forest road gradient on amount of runoff and sediment (Case study: Kohmiyan-Azadshahr forest). J. of Forest and Wood Product. 66: 389-399. (In Persian)
16.Mostafa, M., Shataee Jouibary, S., Lotfalian, M., and Sadoddin, A. 2016. Comparison of geometric characteristics chehel-chay forest watershed roads with rural road standards with an emphasis of runoff products. J. of Wood and Forest Science and Technology. 23: 123-145. (In Persian)
17.Naghdi, R., Dalir, P., Gholami, V., and Pourghasemi, H.R. 2017. Modeling of sediment generation from forest roads employing SEDMODL and its calibration for Hyrcanian forests in northern Iran. Environmental Earth Sciences. 24: 118-125.
18.Parsakhoo, A., Lotfalian, M., Kavian, A., and Hosseini, S.A. 2014. Prediction of the soil erosion risk in a forest and sediment yield from road network through GIS and SEDMODL. International J. of Sediment Research. 29: 1. 118-125.
19.Provencher, Y. 1995. Optimizing road maintenance intervals. In Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Low-Volume Roads, Volume I, Minneapolis, Minnesota, June 25-29, 1995.
20.Sarikhani, N., and Majnonian, B. 1994. Forest roads plan, performance and utilization guide line. Published by Program and Budget Organization of Iran (PBOI). 131: 132-175. (In Persian)
21.Sheridan, G.J., and Noske, P.J. 2007. Catchment-scale contribution of forest roads to stream exports of sediment, phosphorus and nitrogen. Hydrological Processes. 21: 23. 3107-3122.
22.Surfleet, C.G., Skaugset, A.E., and Meadows, M.W. 2011. Road runoff and sediment sampling for determining
road sediment yield at the watershed scale. Canadian J. of Forest Research. 41: 10. 1970-1980.
23.Skaugset, A.E., Surfleet, C.G., Meadows, M.W., and Amann, J. 2011 Evaluation of Erosion Prediction Models for Forest Roads. Low-Volume Roads, Transportation Research Record: J. of the Transportation Research Board.
1: 3-12.
24.Ziegler, A.D., Negishi, J.N., Sidle,R.C., and Gomi, T. 2007. Persistence of road runoff generation in a logged catchment in Peninsular Malaysia.Earth Surface Processes and Landforms. 32: 13. 1947-1970.
Journal of Wood and Forest Science and Technology
Volume 28, Issue 2
September 2021
Pages 75-90

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics