Assessing the risk of windthrow for Eldar pine trees in Sorkhe-Hesar forest park

Document Type : Complete scientific research article

Authors

1 Yazd University

2 YazdUniversity

Abstract

Abstract
Background and objectives: Study of slenderness coefficient and crown ratio of trees in forest parks to determine the stability of the stands against the wind is one of the important issues in the park management. The most important reason is the intensive presence of families and vehicles in these areas, which can cause irreparable damage if trees fall. Therefore, this study was conducted to investigate the sensitivity of Eldar pine trees in different parts of Sorkheh Hesar Forest Park to wind throw. Attempts have also been made to evaluate the suitability of diameter at breast height, as a variable that is simple and inexpensive to measure, to predict the crown ratio and slenderness coefficient as two important indicators for determining the susceptibility of trees to wind throw.

Materials and methods: After a field survey, 14 patches were selected for sampling so that sampling sites were well distributed throughout the park. A total of 151 trees were randomly selected and their diameter at breast height, total height, trunk height, slenderness index and canopy ratio were calculated. Independent t-test was used to examine differences between tree lines and patches. Regression analysis was also performed to model the relationship between diameter-slenderness index as well as diameter-crown ratio.

Results: Based on the results, the average basal area of the measured trees was 0.034 m2 and their average volume was 0.208 m3. Considering the variety of planting spaces, basal area and volume of pine stands were calculated 9.45-54.4 m2. ha-1 and 57.8-332.8 m3. ha-1 respectively. The results showed that the average slenderness index was 57.29% and that 0.7% of the trees were in unstable conditions. The average crown ratio was 0.557 and based on this index, 2.6% of trees were unstable. There was a significant difference between the forest patches and the tree lines along the streets in terms of crown length, canopy ratio, trunk height, and slenderness index. The linear model had a significant fitting to the data of diameter-slenderness index as well as diameter-crown ratio, with error percentage of 13 and 11.7% and coefficient of determination of 0.28 and 0.17, respectively.

Conclusion: In general, pine trees in Sorkheh Hesar National Park are in a stable condition and a small percentage of them need biomechanical study of wood tissues in order to determine the maximum tolerable wind speed and take precautions such as pruning. Also, diameter at the breast height in various plantings in terms of density, alone is not enough to predict the slenderness coefficient and the crown ratio of the trees. It is necessary to measure the total height and crown height of the trees to determine the slenderness coefficient and crown ratio. Due to the effect of the area and shape of tree patches in the incidence and severity of wind throw, it is necessary to consider the shape of the spots as a teardrop that is directed towards the prevailing winds in the region to minimize the risk of falling in busy places.

Keywords

References

1.Abdollahzadeh, B. 2002. Quantitative and qualitative study of Pinus eldarica Medw. in Lavizan Park. Master Thesis, Faculty of Natural resources, Tarbiat Modares University, Iran, 82p. (In Persian)
2.Adeyemi, A.A., Jimoh, S.O., and Adesoye, P.O. 2013. Crown ratio models for tropical rainforests species in Oban division of the cross river national park, Nigeria. J. of Agriculture and Social Research. 13: 1. 63-76.
3.Akhavan, R., and Namiranian, M. 2007. Slenderness coefficient of five major tree species in the Hyrcanian forests of Iran. Iranian, J. of Forest and Poplar Research. 15: 2. 165-180. (In Persian)
4.Amiri, A., and Kiani, B. 2018. Measuring the crown ratio of wild pistachico in the Iran-Turanian Mountain forests. International Conference on Society and Environment. University of Tehran, 8p. (In Persian)
5.Bagheri, R. 2010. Investigation on relationship between wind-throw trees and topography characteristics and stand structure in compartment two of Shastkalateh forest. Gorgan, M.Sc. Thesis, Faculty of Forestry, Gorgan University of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, Iran. 82p. (In Persian)
6.Bozorgi, K., and Sheykholeslami, A. 2016. Survey Slenderness Coefificient of Beech Mixed Trees in Hajikola Tirankoli Area-Sari. J. of Renewable Natural Resources Research. 7: 1 .1-10.
7.Charkazi, A., Amiri, M., Ravanbakhsh, H., and Moghadasi, D. 2016. Examination of Quantitative and Qualitative Characterictics of Cupressus Sempervirens Var. Horizontalis and Pinus Brutia in Plantation Forests in the Ramian, Golestan Province. J. of wood and Forest Science and Technology.23: 4. 1-20. (In Persian)
8.Cucchi, V., Meredieo C., Stokes, A., Coligny, F.D. Suarez, J., and Gardiner, B.A. 2005. Modelling the windthrow risk for simulated forest stands of Maritime pine (Pinus pinaster Ait). Forest Ecology and Management. 213: 1-3. 184-196.
9.Eshaghi Rad, J., Ghaffarnejad, P., and Banedg Shafiee, A. 2014. Quantitative evaluation of Pinus nigra plantation and its effect on plant diversity and soil chemical properties of rangeland ecosystems (Case study: Urmia airport plantation). Iranian, J. of Forest.6: 4. 471-482. (In Persian)
10.Farrokhzadeh, N., Ravanbakhsh, H., Moshki, A., and Mollashahi, M. 2018. The natural regeneration establishment and diversity of different 50-year-old plantation types in Sorkhe-Hesar Forest Park. J. of Forest Research and Development. 4: 1. 43-57. (In Persian)
11.Feghahati, R., and Alvani Nejad, S. 2013. Stability determination of less disturbed forests of Persian oak by trunk coefficient and canopy indices. In: Proceedings of the 1st International Conference of IALE-Iran, Isfahan University of Technology, Iran. 7p.(In Persian)
12.Golpoor, A. 2017. Surveying of some effective ecological factors in windthrow of forest trees (Case study: Chamestan forest- 12 series, forestry plan of west of Haraz). M.Sc. Thesis, Faculty of Desert Studies, Semnan University, Iran. 94p. (In Persian)
13.Hasani, N., and Sinaki, M. 2011. Ability of different tree species in the reduction of mechanical stress of wind in the arid regions, J. of Agronomy Sciences.6: 4. 65-77. (In Persian)
14.JWWR (Jihad of Water and Watershed Researches), 2007. Master plan of development and improvement of Sorkheh-Hesar forest park: Vegetation report. 159p. (In Persian)
15.Kamimura, K., Saito, S., Kinoshita, H., Kitagawa, K., Uchida, T., and Mizunaga, H. 2013. Analysis of wind damage caused by multiple tropical storm events in Japanese Cryptomeria japonica forests, An International J. of Forest Research. 86: 4. 411-420.
16.Kiani, G., Jalilvand, H., and Pourmajidian, M.R. 2013. Diameter increment of Maple tree (Acer velutinum Boiss) in plantations in Mazandaran (Case study: Pahnekola Region). Iranian, J. of Forest Ecology. 1: 2. 86-94.(In Persian)
17.Kiani, B., and Nadi, H. 2016. Comparative investigation of Oriental Plane and White Poplar plantations near Zayanderud dam, Isfahan. Iranian J. of Forest Ecology. 4: 7. 9-17. (In Persian)
18.Luis, N., Jose, T., and Margarida, T. 2010. Stability of pure even-aged conifer stands in Portugal, in IUFRO conference, Mixed and Pure Forests in a Changing World. 6-8 October, Vila Real, Portugal.
19.Lopes, A., Oliveira, S., Fragoso, M., Andrade, J.A., and Pedro, P. 2009.Wind risk assessment in urban environments: The case of falling trees during windstorm events in Lisbon, In: Střelcová K. et al. (eds) Bioclimatology and Natural Hazards. Springer, Dordrecht. pp. 55-74.
20.Mohammadi, J., Shataee, Sh., and Namiranian, M. 2014. Comparison of quantitative and qualitative characteristics of forests structure and composition in natural and managed forest stands (Case study: Shast Kalate forests of Gorgan), J. of Wood and Forest Science and Technology.21: 1. 65-83. (In Persian)
21.Mahmoudian, M. 2005. Successful consideration of Afghan pine (Pinus eldarica) in Ghochak Forest Park, Tehran. M.Sc. Thesis, Natural resources faculty, Mazandaran University, Iran. 94p. (In Persian)
22.Marvie Mohajer, M.R. 2013. Silviculture (4th Edition). Tehran Univ. Press, 386p. (In Persian)
23.Mataji, A. 1999. Investigation of the Distribution of Number in elevated classes in Natural forests (Grazbon section of Nowshahr kheyroudkenar forest). Master Thesis, Faculty of Natural resources, University of Tehran, Iran. 90p. (In Persian)
24.Mataji, A., Akhavan, R., and Aghakhani, S. 2007. Evalution of afforestation success by broad leaf species in Arak city. Iranian, J. of Forest and Poplar Research. 14: 4. 338-359. (In Persian)
25.Maxwell, S., Green, D.S., and Zhang, W. 2010. Identifying the determinants of windthrow damage in wildlife tree patches in the Boreal White and Black Spruce biogeoclimatic zone of northeastern British Columbia, J. of Ecosystems and Management. 10: 3. 1-8.
26.Mossadegh, A. 2010. Afforestation and Forest Nursery (4th Edition). Tehran University Press, 516p. (In Persian)
27.Munishi, P.K.T., and Chamshama, S.A.O. 1994. A study of wind damage on Pinus patula stands in Southern Tanzania. J. of Forest Ecology and Management. 63: 1. 13-21.
28.Ostrovsky, A., Kobza, M., and Gazo, J. 2017. Extensively damaged trees tested with acoustic tomography considering tree stability in urban greenery, Trees. 31. 1015-1023.
29.Pommerening, A. 2007. Basic tree variables, forestry summary characteristics and biodiversity measures. Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SLU), Umea, 34p.
30.Pommerening, A., and Grabarnik, P. 2019. Individual based methods in forest ecology and management, Springer, 411p.
31.Pretzsch, H., Bibera, P., Uhla, E., Dahlhausen, J., Rotzera, Th., Caldenteyb, J., Koike, T., Van Cono, T., Chavanne, A., Seifert, T., Toit, B.D., Farnden, C., and Pauleith, S. 2015. Crown size and growing space requirement of common tree species
in urban centers, parks, and forests, Urban Forestry and Urban Greening.14: 466-479.
32.Rad, M.H., Keneshloo, H., and Soltani, M. 2018. The effects of wastewater irrigation on vegetative performance of various woody species under arid condition (Case study: Yazd city). Iranian, J. of Forest and Poplar Research. 26: 2. 240-251. (In Persian)
33.Rudnicki, M., Silinus, U., and Lieffers, V.J. 2004. Crown cover is correlated with relative density, tree slenderness and tree height in lodgepole pine. J. of Forest science. 50: 3. 356-363.
34.Sabeti, H. 2008. Forests, Trees and Shrubs of Iran (5th Edition), Yazd Univ. Press, 876p. (In Persian) 35.Sasanifar, S., Alijanpour, A.,Banj Shafiei, A., Eshaghi Rad, J., and Molaei, M. 2017. Investigation of Height Parameters and slender coefficient of Trees in Two Protected and Non-Protected Areas of Arasbaran Forests. International Conference on Natural Resources in Developing Countries, Faculty of Natural Recourses, University of Tehran, Iran. 10p.
36.Schindler, D., and Kolbe, S. 2020. Assessment of the Response of a Scots Pine Tree to Effective Wind Loading, Environmental Meteorology, 11: 2. 145.
37.Shayanmehr, F., Jalali, Gh.A., Ghanati, F., and Katoolinejad, D. 2009. The study of conical and ball-shaped pines, two probable mutant forms of Pinus eldarica: comparison of needle anatomy structure. Iranian J. of Forest. 1: 2. 151-161. (In Persian)
Journal of Wood and Forest Science and Technology
Volume 28, Issue 1
June 2021
Pages 37-52

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics